Could France’s law benefit the global workforce?
In today’s hyper-connected digital world, where remote work and constant communication blur the lines between professional and personal life, the issue of work-life balance has become a priority. One country that took decisive action is France,
which introduced its ground-breaking “Right to Disconnect” law in 2017. This law grants employees the legal right to disconnect from work communications—emails, calls, or instant messages—outside of working hours. As global
mobility specialists, we are often tasked with creating equitable, supportive environments for employees across borders. This raises an important question:
Should the French Right to Disconnect be adopted by the global workforce?
Let’s take a closer look at the French law and explore the potential benefits and challenges of implementing such policies on a global scale.
What Is France's 'Right to Disconnect' law?
France’s “Right to Disconnect” law, enacted under Article 55 of the El Khomri Law (Loi Travail) in 2017, was designed to protect employees from the growing expectation of being always available. Companies with more than 50 employees
are required to negotiate rules about work-related communication outside of regular working hours with their workers or unions. This law reflects the broader recognition of the need to safeguard employee well-being in an era where digital tools allow
work to follow employees home.
Should this law be applied globally?
In the global mobility space, where we manage relocations and employee transitions across various regions, the idea of extending a “Right to Disconnect” law worldwide is both intriguing and complex. The need to manage burnout, promote well-being,
and protect boundaries between work and personal life are universal concerns. However, global companies face varying regional work cultures, time zones, and business needs.
Benefits of adopting a global right to disconnect policy
1. Enhanced employee well-being and mental health: A global Right to Disconnect policy would directly address issues like stress, burnout, and mental fatigue, which are on the rise due to the "always-on" work culture. According to the World
Health Organization (WHO), long working hours increase the risk of health problems like stroke and heart disease. By allowing employees to truly disconnect, we can mitigate these risks and foster a healthier work environment. As Dr. Judith Grant,
an occupational health specialist, emphasises, "Prolonged exposure to work without rest leads to burnout and decreased productivity. Disconnecting is essential for mental recovery."
2. Increased productivity: Contrary to fears of lower productivity, research suggests that limiting after-hours communication can actually enhance performance. Studies, like one from the University of Southern California, show that employees who
fully disengage during their personal time
return to work more focused and motivated. Employees who are well-rested perform better, and organisations benefit from improved efficiency.
3. Improved workplace culture and retention: Implementing a Right to Disconnect globally could promote a more positive workplace culture, signalling to employees that their time and well-being are valued. In today's competitive talent market, particularly
among Millennials and Gen Z, a company’s commitment to work-life balance can be a key differentiator. A well-structured disconnect policy could boost employee satisfaction and retention, contributing to a more loyal and engaged workforce.
Challenges of adopting a global right to disconnect policy
1. Diverse global operations and time zones: The complexity of managing multinational teams makes the idea of a global Right to Disconnect policy challenging. Time zones alone present a significant hurdle—what is "after hours" for one employee
may be normal working hours for another. For companies operating across continents, this could disrupt essential business operations, particularly for teams that rely on real-time collaboration.
Ian MacGregor, a global HR consultant, highlights the difficulty: “Managing a Right to Disconnect policy across multiple time zones requires flexibility and careful planning to avoid disruptions in global communication.”
2. Reduced responsiveness in critical sectors: Industries like technology, finance, and customer service depend on rapid response times, even outside standard business hours. In these sectors, employees often need to be available after hours to
handle emergencies or provide support. A strict disconnect policy could slow response times, affecting critical business functions such as IT troubleshooting or crisis management, where downtime is costly.
3. Cultural differences and employee expectations: Cultural attitudes toward work and personal time vary significantly across the globe. In some regions, particularly parts of Asia, working late or being available after hours is seen as a mark
of dedication and commitment. Implementing a Right to Disconnect policy in these regions might conflict with local work culture, leading to employee dissatisfaction or resistance.
Alternatives to a global right to disconnect policy
Instead of a one-size-fits-all approach, global mobility specialists can consider more flexible alternatives that respect cultural and operational differences:
- Flexible working hours: Giving employees the flexibility to set their own hours within a given framework allows them to manage when they work and when they disconnect.
- Encouraging rest and downtime: Organisations can actively promote taking breaks and completely disconnecting during vacations without enforcing strict legal rules.
- Role-specific disconnect policies: Tailoring policies based on job roles and responsibilities ensures that critical functions, such as tech support, are covered while still protecting the well-being of employees who can afford stricter disconnect
times.
Conclusion
France’s Right to Disconnect law sets an important precedent for protecting employee well-being in an increasingly digital world. However, extending such policies to a global workforce presents unique challenges. While the benefits of a global Right
to Disconnect are clear—improved mental health, productivity, and company culture—the practicalities of enforcing this law across diverse work cultures, time zones, and industries are complex.
Global mobility specialists play a critical role in navigating these challenges, advocating for flexible, region-specific solutions that respect both employee well-being and the operational needs of the business. Ultimately, fostering a culture of balance
and respect for personal time is essential, whether or not a formal Right to Disconnect law is implemented globally
Source:
French Ministry of Labor, “Labor Code, Right to Disconnect” - Ministry of Labor World Health Organisation, “Mental Health in the Workplace” - WHO
Eurofound, “Working Anytime, Anywhere” - Eurofound
Harvard Business Review, “The Productivity Benefits of a Right to Disconnect” - Harvard Business Review
Mercer, “Global Talent Trends” - Mercer
McKinsey & Company, “Work-Life Balance Across Borders” - McKinsey
International Labour Organization, “Future of Work” - ILO
Click here to participate in the poll